Assistive technology in adult social care

Assistive technology in adult social care

Councils not yet tapping potential of assistive technology in adult social care

Survey of English local authorities reveals savings-focused use of telecare and other technologies can compound recipients’ isolation and loneliness

Local authorities’ using telecare and other assistive technologies are failing to exploit more than a fraction of the potential benefits to recipients and their families, new research by the Social Care Workforce Research Unit at KCL has found.

A survey of all English councils with social care responsibilities, backed up by selective interviews, found almost all deployed telecare as part of a strategy to reduce the need for care, safeguard and enhance quality of life.

Authorities, which are having to deal with rising social care demand at a time of shrinking resources, had mostly developed their approaches “unilaterally”, with only a quarter working collaboratively with health partners.

The study, funded by NIHR SSCR, found considerable variation in the quality of assessments for telecare.

It also concluded that reviews of systems, often carried out remotely, tended to focus on the performance of equipment rather than on the needs of users.

Diane Buddery, a project manager at the Skills for Care charity, said the study posed questions for councils as to why assistive technology’s positive potential was “not mirrored by sufficient investment or development of skilled staff”.

She added that Skills for Care would be continuing work to promote learning and skills around assistive technology provision. The study raised a number of considerations for practice improvements, including around investment in training and better recognition of how telecare could be used to identify and address loneliness.

Risk management

The research found most local authorities used assistive technology to manage risks faced by older people around independent living, for example by using sensors to monitor their routines, or enabling them to call for assistance.

The online survey revealed that assessments were “conducted by a range of community professionals, including social workers, care managers, occupational therapists [and] specialist telecare workers” and in a variety of settings.

The assessments were variously carried out separately or as part of wider evaluations of need, with only 16% of councils saying that a formal assessment was ‘always’ carried out before an installation. Less than half of councils provided training to telecare assessors; in most cases this was delivered by an equipment manufacturer and was not accredited.

While most authorities reviewed assistive technology installations annually, the survey found “reviews are usually done by telephone and often seemed to focus on the technology, not the needs of the telecare user”.

Only a third of authorities described their telecare service as “person-centred”, in that it avoided standardised packages in favour of prescription according to specific needs and the ability to deliver bespoke packages. More than a fifth said their service was part person-centred and part service-driven.

Compounding isolation

The study concluded that many local authorities are using assistive technology in a “problematic” way, “because of the potential [for it] to compound social isolation”.

The strategic focus on managing independent living was too narrow, it concluded, with almost no local authorities considering how technology might be used to address feelings of loneliness.

“Many ‘false alarms’ made to call centres may arise from a need for human contact, and this should be recognised rather than seen as an inappropriate use of a device,” the research report said.

The study recommended that councils should consider whether different groups of professionals had the necessary skills to optimise the benefits of assistive technology installations.

“Given the level of investment in telecare, exploration of training effectiveness and more investment in training might help better equip assessors – regardless of professional background – with the skills to enable recipients to get the best out of telecare,” the report said.

‘Barriers to better use’

Responding to the findings, Skills for Care’s Diane Buddery said the organisation, which seeks to promote skills and leadership in adult social care, welcomed the study:

“The report found that skill deficits among professional staff responsible for assessing for telecare, and lack of staff with the right skills to install telecare, were cited by commissioners and senior managers as barriers to better use of telecare.
While this study demonstrates wide agreement about the many positive aspects of telecare, it poses questions about why this is not mirrored by sufficient investment or development of skilled staff, who can maximise imaginative and knowledgeable solutions from a wide range of suppliers to meet need.”

Full summary findings

NIHR SSCR (2018) Is There a Clearer Role for Electronic Assistive Technology and Telecare in Adult Social Care?, Research Findings 89, NIHR School for Social Care Research, London.

Further information

This study funded by the NIHR School for Social Care Research and led by Dr John Woolham in the Social Care Workforce Research Unit at King’s College London.

Sunday, September 30th, 2018

Other news

Research Career Development Awards – Call for Applications Funding


25 November 2024

Research Career Development Awards – Call for Applications

The NIHR School for Social Care Research (SSCR) is dedicated to improving the evidence base of social care practice in...

Paper: Co-Producing Resources to Raise Awareness of Meals on Wheels Findings


14 June 2024

Paper: Co-Producing Resources to Raise Awareness of Meals on Wheels

Paper from the University of Bristol describes work to co-produce knowledge translation resources with people with lived experience of Meals...

Paper: Care Relationships in Social Care Residential Settings Findings


15 May 2024

Paper: Care Relationships in Social Care Residential Settings

Paper describes findings from a literature review exploring care relationships between support staff and adults with a learning disability in...

Paper: Unpaid carers of people with dementia and ICT Findings


25 April 2024

Paper: Unpaid carers of people with dementia and ICT

Paper from the London School of Economics and Political Science explored the types of information communication technology (ICT) unpaid carers...

Paper: People with learning disabilities renting their own homes Findings


24 February 2024

Paper: People with learning disabilities renting their own homes

Findings from project led by the University of York looking at the rented housing sector for people with learning disabilities.

Supporting older people’s care moves Blog post


23 February 2024

Supporting older people’s care moves

Transitions between care settings: how evidence-based resources can help

Food and drink in later life: the role of homecare Blog post


21 February 2024

Food and drink in later life: the role of homecare

What is the role of homecare in tackling undernourishment in older adults?

Exploring the benefits of music in care homes Blog post


19 December 2023

Exploring the benefits of music in care homes

How care home residents and staff can benefit from music-making

Data-Driven Decision-Making in Homelessness Services Blog post


14 December 2023

Data-Driven Decision-Making in Homelessness Services

How can choice modelling provide better services for people experiencing homelessness?

Funding of £10 million for prevention research News


4 October 2023

Funding of £10 million for prevention research

NIHR Three Research Schools awarded £10 million to deliver programme of prevention research.

‘What’s your 10 minutes of Britney Spears?’ The key to a flourishing life Blog post


4 October 2023

‘What’s your 10 minutes of Britney Spears?’ The key to a flourishing life

Finding the key to a flourishing life: applying a Capability Approach to social care

NIHR announces Research Support Service News


18 July 2023

NIHR announces Research Support Service

New NIHR Research Support Service to provide application support for researchers.

New Catalogue of Social Care Data News


13 April 2023

New Catalogue of Social Care Data

First fully comprehensive catalogue of social care data launched.

Supporting A Charter for Social Work Research in Adult Social Care News


20 February 2023

Supporting A Charter for Social Work Research in Adult Social Care

NIHR SSCR joins with other organisations to support A Charter for Social Work Research in Adult Social Care.

Dementia Career Development Awards – Call for applications Funding


26 June 2024

Dementia Career Development Awards – Call for applications

NIHR Three Schools' Dementia Research Programme invites applications to support individuals to develop their careers in dementia-related research by 16...

Call for Outline Research Proposals 2024 – Dementia Funding


26 June 2024

Call for Outline Research Proposals 2024 – Dementia

NIHR Three Schools' Dementia Research Programme invites outline research proposals for up to £500,000 by 23 September 2024.