New evidence on use of Covid ‘easements’ by local authorities

New evidence on use of Covid ‘easements’ by local authorities

At the start of the Covid pandemic in 2020 the UK government legislated to relax its requirements for local authorities to deliver adult social care services. These ‘easements’ to the Care Act were intended to aid local authority management of social care and provide legal protections during a period of uncertainty and crisis.   

New research funded by the School is investigating how and why the easements of the Coronavirus Act were put in place, and their impact. The study was one of the projects funded by NIHR SSCR looking at the impact of the pandemic on social care. For the first phase of the project, researchers at the NIHR Health & Social Care Workforce Research Unit, based at King’s College London, carried out interviews with key informants working in the adult social care sector, in order to gather their perspectives on emergency measures. These included lawyers, government officials, and advisors in leading charities and smaller grass-roots charities.  

The study, led by Dr Mary Baginsky, highlights the ways in which different stakeholders viewed the measures. Interviewees from the Department of Health & Social Care tended to see the emergency measures as a reasonable way of reducing the strain on local authorities. They were ‘a necessary piece of legislation that no-one wanted to write’, enabling local authorities to continue to meet essential needs even if they were not able to meet all duties prescribed by the Care Act. Many others, however, were opposed to the easements, reasoning that ‘if laws had been introduced to protect the most vulnerable people in society, they should not be suspended during a public health crisis.’ 

One participant described the easements as a ‘knee-jerk response, rather than a thoughtful response to what was actually necessary in the circumstances’. A particular concern was ‘the provision that allowed LAs to suspend their duty to meet a person’s eligible needs, except where this would breach their rights under the European Convention on Human Rights (ECHR).’ The researchers note that ‘the British Association of Social Workers (BASW) referred to this threshold as ‘vague’ and called for its removal.’ 

Some interviewees believed those authorities that did adopt the easements could not have proved their use was essential, nor would they have been able to properly inform people accessing social care of their new rights and entitlements. However, ultimately only a small number of local authorities in England adopted the temporary easements and those that did, opted out of them by July 2020. This did not necessarily reflect areas affected the most by Covid – no London local authority, for example, adopted the easements, despite the region having high numbers of Covid cases in this period. A national campaign against the easements ‘may have led LAs to stop using them just a few weeks or months after triggering their introduction and to others deciding not to follow that path.’  

In Phase 2 of this study, the researchers have been gathering the perspectives and experiences of local authorities (either who adopted the easements or did not), and the individuals affected by easements. It is hoped that the evidence gathered during both phases of the study will provide insights which may guide responses to future pandemics and other emergencies.  

Follow future project findings and outputs on the NIHR SSCR project page.

Full article

Baginsky, M., Thomas, E. & Manthorpe, J (2022) The Coronavirus Act’s Easements to the Care Act 2014: A Pragmatic Response or a Red Herring?The British Journal of Social Work.

Wednesday, March 30th, 2022

Other news

When design researchers and academic researchers meet: three challenges of interdisciplinary research Blog post


6 September 2023

When design researchers and academic researchers meet: three challenges of interdisciplinary research

When design researchers and academic researchers meet

Call for Outline Research Proposals – Dementia Funding


14 August 2023

Call for Outline Research Proposals – Dementia

NIHR Three Schools' Dementia Research Programme invites outline research proposals for up to £500,000 by 22 September 2023.

Top tips for delivering co-production workshops Blog post


4 August 2023

Top tips for delivering co-production workshops

Top tips for delivering co-production workshops

NIHR announces Research Support Service News


18 July 2023

NIHR announces Research Support Service

New NIHR Research Support Service to provide application support for researchers.

Using service design methods to strengthen innovation in social care Blog post


13 July 2023

Using service design methods to strengthen innovation in social care

Using service design methods to strengthen innovation in social care

Local authority priorities: brokering knowledge in Adult Social Care Blog post


13 June 2023

Local authority priorities: brokering knowledge in Adult Social Care

Disrupting academic-policy exchange by focussing on local authority priorities for research

Developing CASCID, a new centralised catalogue for social care data Blog post


23 May 2023

Developing CASCID, a new centralised catalogue for social care data

How researchers developed a new centralised catalogue of social care data

Removing the barriers to social care research in practice Blog post


2 May 2023

Removing the barriers to social care research in practice

A new tool to support social care research in practice

SSCR – a place and a space Blog post


19 April 2023

SSCR – a place and a space

Reflections on the past and future of social care research

New Catalogue of Social Care Data News


13 April 2023

New Catalogue of Social Care Data

First fully comprehensive catalogue of social care data launched.

Supporting the intimate lives of autistic adults Blog post


4 April 2023

Supporting the intimate lives of autistic adults

How adult social care can better support intimate relationships of autistic people

Supporting A Charter for Social Work Research in Adult Social Care News


20 February 2023

Supporting A Charter for Social Work Research in Adult Social Care

NIHR SSCR joins with other organisations to support A Charter for Social Work Research in Adult Social Care.

Four social care professionals appointed as NIHR SSCR Practice-Based Research Leaders News


21 February 2023

Four social care professionals appointed as NIHR SSCR Practice-Based Research Leaders

Four social care professionals appointed as NIHR SSCR Practice-Based Research Leaders.

Funding of £1.25 million committed to dementia research News


3 February 2023

Funding of £1.25 million committed to dementia research

Funding of £1.25 million has been committed to seven new research projects into dementia through the NIHR Three Schools' Dementia...

Carers involvement in research News


17 November 2022

Carers involvement in research

A new report published by the School with support from the NIHR Centre for Engagement and Dissemination focuses on carers...