Communication passports

Communication passports

Communication passports were generally poor and did not result in better communication, study finds

Research found that communication support did not appear to be targeted at those who experience the greatest communication challenges

Improved staff training about communication and interaction is needed, a study led by Jill Bradshaw at the University of Kent has concluded.

Communication needs

At least 45% of people with learning disabilities experience serious problems with communication. Communication passports are a tool for supporting people who cannot easily speak for themselves by making information from formal assessments easily accessible to all. A good communication passport clearly describes communication strengths and needs.

Dr Jill Bradshaw and colleagues aimed to explore the use of communication passports and the quality of communication in adult social care for people with intellectual and development disabilities. They also looked at whether having a communication passport resulted in better communication.

The research team recruited 29 service users in total, including 10 passport users, with full data collected on 24 of them. They carried out 18 communication assessments and had assessment data on 22 individuals. The study included interviews with staff (60), family members (5), and service users (5),  questionnaires from 28 individuals, observation of 24 individuals, and review of existing communication assessments for the eight people who had them.

For the participants in the study, staff described them as needing a variety of communication methods, including verbal communication (86%), gestures (44%), symbols (20%) and signed communication (7%).

The quality of communication passports

The study was unable to recruit participants who had passports of good quality.

Of the participants in the study who had communication passports, these were of poor quality, limited individualisation, were not accessible and the information they contained was vague.

The research found that having either a communication passport or assessment did not result in better agreement about communication skills.

Overall, staff communication in the study was not rated as more appropriate if person had a communication passport, and it was not rated as more appropriate if person had a speech and language therapy assessment.

Communication support

The study found that there was very limited formal use of alternative and augmentative communication, with many interactions being only verbal, despite service users needing additional support from visual means of communication. Some staff appeared to think they had a choice about whether or not to use additional forms of communication.

People were observed to receive contact of any type from staff for 15% of the time on average (range 0–47%) – equating to an average of nine minutes in every hour. Those people with verbal communication skills received better support for communication.

In the interviews that were carried out with the service users using Talking Mats, participants reflected that staff tended to do things for people rather than support people to do things for themselves. Participants reported having little choice over activities.

Implications

The study suggests that the quality of support for communications is a reflection of:

  • the lack of knowledge about service user communication strengths and needs and how to address these;
  • missed opportunities to engage in communication and interaction;
  • lack of knowledge about (and value given to) alternative and augmentative communication;
  • misunderstandings about choice;
  • lack of knowledge about the need for structure and predictability; and
  • differences in understanding about the role of staff in supporting engagement in activities,  communication and relationships.

The research team concluded that better (statutory) training about communication and interaction is needed, including skills in person-centred active support, alternative and augmentative communication and providing positive and enabling environments.

Better information is also needed regarding individual’s communication strengths and needs, both from formal assessments and from sharing information across teams and between families and those working in services.

Full summary findings

NIHR SSCR (2020) Evaluating the Impact of Communication Passports, Research Findings 124, NIHR School for Social Care Research, London.

Further information

This study was funded by the NIHR School for Social Care Research and led by Jill Bradshaw at the University of Kent.

The findings were completed before COVID-19 and have been published to support NIHR SSCR’s requirement that findings from all completed studies are made publicly available.

Tuesday, September 29th, 2020

Other news

Research Career Development Awards – Call for Applications Funding


25 November 2024

Research Career Development Awards – Call for Applications

The NIHR School for Social Care Research (SSCR) is dedicated to improving the evidence base of social care practice in...

Paper: Co-Producing Resources to Raise Awareness of Meals on Wheels Findings


14 June 2024

Paper: Co-Producing Resources to Raise Awareness of Meals on Wheels

Paper from the University of Bristol describes work to co-produce knowledge translation resources with people with lived experience of Meals...

Paper: Care Relationships in Social Care Residential Settings Findings


15 May 2024

Paper: Care Relationships in Social Care Residential Settings

Paper describes findings from a literature review exploring care relationships between support staff and adults with a learning disability in...

Paper: Unpaid carers of people with dementia and ICT Findings


25 April 2024

Paper: Unpaid carers of people with dementia and ICT

Paper from the London School of Economics and Political Science explored the types of information communication technology (ICT) unpaid carers...

Paper: People with learning disabilities renting their own homes Findings


24 February 2024

Paper: People with learning disabilities renting their own homes

Findings from project led by the University of York looking at the rented housing sector for people with learning disabilities.

Supporting older people’s care moves Blog post


23 February 2024

Supporting older people’s care moves

Transitions between care settings: how evidence-based resources can help

Food and drink in later life: the role of homecare Blog post


21 February 2024

Food and drink in later life: the role of homecare

What is the role of homecare in tackling undernourishment in older adults?

Exploring the benefits of music in care homes Blog post


19 December 2023

Exploring the benefits of music in care homes

How care home residents and staff can benefit from music-making

Data-Driven Decision-Making in Homelessness Services Blog post


14 December 2023

Data-Driven Decision-Making in Homelessness Services

How can choice modelling provide better services for people experiencing homelessness?

Funding of £10 million for prevention research News


4 October 2023

Funding of £10 million for prevention research

NIHR Three Research Schools awarded £10 million to deliver programme of prevention research.

‘What’s your 10 minutes of Britney Spears?’ The key to a flourishing life Blog post


4 October 2023

‘What’s your 10 minutes of Britney Spears?’ The key to a flourishing life

Finding the key to a flourishing life: applying a Capability Approach to social care

NIHR announces Research Support Service News


18 July 2023

NIHR announces Research Support Service

New NIHR Research Support Service to provide application support for researchers.

New Catalogue of Social Care Data News


13 April 2023

New Catalogue of Social Care Data

First fully comprehensive catalogue of social care data launched.

Supporting A Charter for Social Work Research in Adult Social Care News


20 February 2023

Supporting A Charter for Social Work Research in Adult Social Care

NIHR SSCR joins with other organisations to support A Charter for Social Work Research in Adult Social Care.

Dementia Career Development Awards – Call for applications Funding


26 June 2024

Dementia Career Development Awards – Call for applications

NIHR Three Schools' Dementia Research Programme invites applications to support individuals to develop their careers in dementia-related research by 16...

Call for Outline Research Proposals 2024 – Dementia Funding


26 June 2024

Call for Outline Research Proposals 2024 – Dementia

NIHR Three Schools' Dementia Research Programme invites outline research proposals for up to £500,000 by 23 September 2024.